Home
 
Previous | Memories | Tell a Friend | Next
 
Cinzia
cinzia81
13 November 2009 @ 06:06 pm
PS I love you...  
Today I finished this book. I really enjoyed it but I didn't loved it as much as the movie. I saw the movie and I really loved it. Gerry played by Butler is perfect (He really is 'Gerry'...that's cool!) I want a Gerry too :( Daniel was lovely and Holly doesn't have 432.023.432 of brothers and sisters! At the beginning of the book it was hard to know each one of them. One of the thing I loved the most about the book is that, despite the fact that it's a love story (the kind of book I hate the most) it's not too much sweet. It explain of difficult is to grow for a girl who is near thirty like me so I could recognize in different situations she lived also if she did lots and lots of things for her young age. Another thing I loved is the fact that Gerry was so amazing to be on the book since the end also if he wasn't there and in both book and movie I felt sad for his death but tecnically we didn't know him...but he was so awesome that we felt Holly's pain. Something that I didn't like is how it ended between Holly and Daniel! I hope that they will end togheter at least on the book and if the message have to be that they are not meant to be, I prefer their story on the movie, that kiss and the fact that was like kiss a brother/sister plus the movie has JD Morgan that in the book doen't exist! So, if you have read the book and see the movie, what do you prefer? Have you enjoyed this story? What's your opinion about it?
 
15 comments | Leave a comment
 
( 15 comments — Post a new comment )
Ana: [Actress] Sophia Bush ♥[info]an_aiko on November 13th, 2009 08:35 pm (UTC)
I haven't seen the movie , or read the book ... =S

But I'll put them on my list ^^
Cinzia[info]cinzia81 on November 14th, 2009 07:45 pm (UTC)
I suggest you do do at least one of those thing (read the book or watch the movie) because the story deserve it! I wasn't even interested in it and now, here I am to suggest you to take allok at it :P
ioio10[info]ioio10 on November 13th, 2009 11:12 pm (UTC)
Io ho visto il film (più volte eheh) e l'ho ADORATO *_______________* ... il libro non l'ho letto, ma la mia amica che l'ha fatto dice che le sono piaciuti entrambi...
Cinzia: David Boreanaz - Laugh @ ComicCon[info]cinzia81 on November 14th, 2009 07:51 pm (UTC)
Ma CIAO!!!!!!!!! che bello risentirti!!! Spero che le cose vadano meglio!!! Io intanto ti mandi un abbraccione forte forte!!! Mi fa tanto piacere rileggerti!!!


Io il film l'ho visto a metà libro e ho notato che è tanto diverso!!! Il senso e il clima è quello ma la trama è stravolta! io però ho adorato Butler nel ruolo di gerry e...fortunata Holly che l'ha avuto, anche se per poco, nella sua vita...che uomo meraviglioso! Riescono a fartelo amare anche se non ce lo fanno mai conoscere....nel film amo quando lui all'inizio esce dal bagno in mutande con le bretelle...mi ha fatto troppo ridere XD poi nel film c'è JD Morgan che merita eccome XD mentre nel libro è più triste il personaggio che lo dovrebbe rappresentare... meglio lui e meglio come finisce nel film soprattutto la storia con daniel! io speravo che almeno nel libro si mettessero insieme e invece.... mah ....
ioio10: B&B[info]ioio10 on November 15th, 2009 07:38 pm (UTC)
Grazie! Si, un pochettino meglio si, ancora non bene, ma sicuramente non ultramale come prima...

Si si anche la mia amica mi ha raccontato tutte le differenze nella trama! XD Su Gerry concordo anch'io *_* adoro Gerard Butler e in questo film l'ho amato <3 la scena delle bretelle è ormai mitica ahah avevo fatto anche delle gif su quella scena, vediamo se ritrovo il post!
Ecco, appunto, anche JDM contribuisce a far sbavare la gente davanti a sto film XD (e la mia amica adorava anche James Marsters, quindi puoi capire come stava mentre eravamo al cinema ihih XD)
Alcune scene le so a memoria XD è spettacolare quella del "Sei single? Sei gay? Hai un lavoro?" XD, poi quella sulla barca con i giubbottini, quella del cane, ecc... e poi c'è lo sfondo dell'Irlanda *_*
Ok, potrei parlare ore di sto film ;-) intanto vado a cercare il post...
eccoloooo http://ioio10.livejournal.com/27323.html#cutid1 , cavolo è più di un anno fa... bei tempi -_-
Cinzia: David Boreanaz - Laugh @ ComicCon[info]cinzia81 on November 15th, 2009 08:10 pm (UTC)
Non hai idea di quanto piacere mi faccia sentirti così!

A proposito del film hai ragionissima ... è molto bello ed emozionante! E' vero che c'è pure James! io non impazzisco per lui, in buffy, te lo sai, io son sempre stata per angel e david ma fa sempre piacere rivedere spike in giro quindi si, anche lui è un motivo per vedere il film! Le gif le ho viste e commentate! Sono splendide!!! *__* La versione filmica di Denise è straordinaria (Phoebe di Friends!!! Altro motivo per cui vale la pena vedere il film!!! Certo che a Lisa i ruoli da pazzoide calzano proprio a pennello eh XD povera...) io il film poi l'ho visto in lingua originale e rende anche di più! Un altro del film che ho amato è stato Daniel! Peccato sia finita così tra loro però bella la loro amicizia...
Susi[info]pasadora on November 14th, 2009 09:25 am (UTC)
I only saw the movie but I haven't read the book. Heard it's a little different, that's why I wanted to check it out. :)
Cinzia[info]cinzia81 on November 14th, 2009 07:54 pm (UTC)
Oh yes, the book very different from the movie and I think this is the first time in my life where I prefer the movie! The atmosphere is the same but the story is completly different! Just as example Holly in the movie come from America and only Gerry is Irish while, in the book both are Irish. This is just one of the thousand different thing but the movie is awesome and I loved the story!
elfert[info]elfert on November 14th, 2009 02:25 pm (UTC)
Saw the movie first then read the book :)
I like both very much. The plot of the stories are the same but they are two different stories. I think it was better to see the movie before reading the book. Anyways, I'm a fan of both and I do own the book & the movie :)
Cinzia[info]cinzia81 on November 14th, 2009 07:56 pm (UTC)
I don't want to say something worn but I'm pretty sure that I saw the movie and I bought the book because of you! You suggest me to watch the movie first and I listen to you at 50% because in my experience it's always better read the book first so I start to read the book and when I was in the middle of the story I saw the movie and I LOVED it! Gerry was awesome!!! loved also Butler and Hilary as Gerry and holly! They were perfect for the role but honestly I prefered the movie.... you were right! :P Thanks for the suggestion. What are you reading now?!!? XD
elfert[info]elfert on November 14th, 2009 08:56 pm (UTC)
Nope, you're right :)
I did suggest the book & the movie. Glad you enjoyed both.

Butler & Hilary were awesome! I pictured them when I was reading the book :)

Not really reading anything at the moment. I'm planning on watching My Sister's Keeper and then read the book. Do you have any suggestions?
Cinzia[info]cinzia81 on November 14th, 2009 10:31 pm (UTC)
before this I read Time Traveler's Wife. I don't know if you've already read it but it's very very nice and, most of all...very original! I can't wait to watch the movie now! Before that I read World without End...I have still to finish it because this book is "without end" but it's one of the most amazing book I've ever read! Ken Follet is Awesome so I suggest you that. There are no movie for that book but it deserve to be read! I hope to finish it soon!
elfert[info]elfert on November 16th, 2009 02:59 am (UTC)
I was thinking about reading that but I think I neeed to watch the movie first.. Looks like to movie was a big letdown.

Thanks, might that one out too :)
Cinzia[info]cinzia81 on November 16th, 2009 10:27 am (UTC)
Honestly I think that PS I love you was an exception but usually it's better read the book first...
elfert[info]elfert on November 16th, 2009 01:13 pm (UTC)
True. Well, whatever I get first will be what I read/watch first :P